Part 2
Addresses the decline of virtue, the application of Tao to governance, and the paradoxical nature of strength and weakness.
46 argumentative units
- 01The Decline from Highest Virtue
How possessing virtue in highest degree means not seeking to show it, while lower degrees require constant effort.
- 02The Stages of Degeneration
The Tao's loss brings attributes, then benevolence, righteousness, and finally the proprieties that mark disorder.
- 03All Things Derive from the One
Heaven, earth, spirits, valleys, creatures, and rulers all receive their essential qualities from the One.
- 04Dignity Rooted in Meanness
True dignity finds its foundation in meanness, as princes calling themselves orphans acknowledge.
- 05The Movement of the Tao
The Tao proceeds by contraries and weakness, generating existence from non-existence.
- 06Three Classes of Scholars
Scholars respond differently to the Tao—highest practice it, middle waver, lowest laugh at it.
- 07The Tao's Production of All Things
The Tao produces One, which produces Two, then Three, then all things harmonized by Vacancy.
- 08The Soft Overcoming the Hard
Water, the softest thing, overcomes the hardest through non-action and teaching without words.
- 09Fame, Life, and Wealth
Clinging to fame or wealth brings sorrow; contentment without shame enables long life.
- 10Great Achievements Deemed Poor
Seeming crooked, stupid, and stammering while acting with purity and stillness gives the correct law.
- 11When the Tao Prevails or Is Disregarded
The Tao prevailing brings peace; disregarded, it brings war and the evils of ambition.
- 12Understanding Without Going Out
True knowledge comes without travel; sages name things without seeing them and accomplish without purpose.
- 13Learning Versus the Tao
Learning seeks increase, the Tao seeks decrease until arriving at non-action that accomplishes everything.
- 14The Sage's Invariable Mind
The sage has no fixed mind but adopts the people's mind, treating all with goodness and sincerity.
- 15Ministers of Life and Death
Of every ten, three minister to life, three to death, three tend toward death through excessive striving.
- 16The Tao Produces and Nourishes All
The Tao produces, nourishes, and completes all things without claiming possession or control.
- 17The Mother of All Under Heaven
The Tao is the mother; knowing one is her child, guard her qualities for lifelong safety.
- 18Fear of Boastful Display
The great Tao is level and easy, yet people prefer by-ways and ostentatious living contrary to it.
- 19What the Skilful Planter Plants
What the Tao plants cannot be uprooted; its influence extends through person, family, neighborhood, state, and kingdom.
- 20Abundant Attributes Like an Infant
One with abundant Tao resembles an infant—protected, firm in grasp, perfectly harmonious.
- 21He Who Knows Does Not Speak
Those who know the Tao keep silent, blunt sharp points, and achieve the Mysterious Agreement.
- 22Ruling by Correction or Freedom
A state ruled by correction multiplies prohibitions and disorder; freedom from action transforms the people naturally.
- 23Government That Seems Unwise
The least meddling government brings goodness; happiness and misery lie side by side unpredictably.
- 24Moderation for Serving Heaven
Moderation enables early return to normal state and subjugation of obstacles to govern long.
- 25Governing Like Cooking Small Fish
Govern according to the Tao and spirits will not harm men; sage and spirits converge in virtue.
- 26A Great State Like a Low Stream
A great state becomes the center by lowering itself; stillness and abasement win adherents.
- 27The Tao's Most Honoured Place
The Tao holds the most honored place, guarding bad men and able to be sought for redemption.
- 28Acting Without Thinking of Acting
The Tao acts without purpose, considers small as great, recompenses injury with kindness.
- 29That Which Is at Rest
Act before things appear, secure order before disorder begins; the journey of a thousand li starts with a single step.
- 30Making the People Simple and Ignorant
Ancients practiced the Tao to make people simple, not enlightened; governing by wisdom scourges the state.
- 31Rivers and Seas Receive Tribute
Rivers and seas rule by being lower; the sage rules by placing himself below and behind others.
- 32Three Precious Things
The Tao's greatness seems inferior; three treasures are gentleness, economy, and shrinking from precedence.
- 33Skill in War Without Contending
True skill in war avoids contention, marshals without ranks, and bends men's wills like Heaven.
- 34Marshalling Where There Are No Ranks
Prefer defense to offense, advance without weapons; lightly engaging in war risks losing precious gentleness.
- 35Easy to Know, Hard to Practice
The sage's words are easy to know and practice, yet no one can do so; they contain a comprehending principle.
- 36To Know and Think We Do Not Know
True knowledge is knowing yet thinking we do not know; recognizing disease as pain preserves us from it.
- 37When the People Do Not Fear
When people lose proper fear, great dread comes; the sage knows himself but does not parade knowledge.
- 38Boldness in Daring or Not Daring
Boldness to do wrong brings death; Heaven's way conquers without striving, its net catches all.
- 39The People Do Not Fear Death
Using death threats when people don't fear death is futile; one presides over death like a great carpenter.
- 40The People Suffer from Famine
Famine comes from excessive taxes; difficulty in governing from meddling; leaving life out of view is better.
- 41Man at Birth Supple and Weak
At birth supple and weak, at death firm and strong; firmness accompanies death, softness life.
- 42The Way of Heaven Like Bending a Bow
Heaven diminishes superabundance and supplements deficiency; only the Tao-possessor serves all under heaven.
- 43Nothing More Soft Than Water
Water, soft and weak, overcomes the hard and strong; true words seem paradoxical.
- 44After Great Animosity a Grudge Remains
After reconciliation a grudge remains; the sage keeps the record but doesn't insist on fulfillment.
- 45A Little State with Small Population
In a little state with few people, avoid using abilities, make death grievous, return to simple ways.
- 46Sincere Words Are Not Fine
Sincere words aren't fine, the skilled don't dispute, the sage doesn't accumulate but gives freely.