Chapter XV
Paternal, political, and despotical powers differ in origins and limits; only political power serves the public good.
13 argumentative units
- 01Necessity of distinguishing three powers
Locke argues that recent mistakes about government stem from confusing paternal, political, and despotical powers, making it necessary to examine them together to clarify the distinctions.
- 02Definition of paternal power
Paternal power is parental authority over children until they reach the age of reason, aimed at their instruction and preservation, not arbitrary rule.
- 03Natural basis and limits of parental authority
God's implantation of affection in parents shows paternal power is benevolent and temporary, not extending to life and death or persisting after children reach adulthood.
- 04Definition of political power
Political power originates from individuals giving up their natural powers to society through compact, to be used for the preservation of life, liberty, and property.
- 05Natural right and legitimate constraints on political power
Political power in nature involves using means to preserve one's property and punishing breaches of natural law; magistrates hold this power with the same measure and must not be absolute.
- 06Origins of political power in consent
Political power derives its legitimacy solely from compact and mutual consent of those constituting the community.
- 07Definition of despotical power
Despotical power is the absolute, arbitrary power one man may hold over another's life, existing only through natural forfeiture when an aggressor initiates war.
- 08Despotical power lacks natural or compact foundation
Despotical power originates neither from nature nor from compact, since no man has arbitrary power over his own life to transfer to another.
- 09Despotical power arises from forfeiture through war
Despotical power results only from forfeiture when an aggressor abandons reason and initiates war, rendering himself liable to destruction as a dangerous beast.
- 10Despotical power limited to lawful captives
Only captives taken in just war are subject to despotical power, and this power ceases when a captive enters into compact and becomes master of his own life.
- 11Summary of origins of the three powers
Nature grants paternal power to parents for children's benefit during minority; voluntary agreement grants political power to governors for subjects' benefit; forfeiture grants despotical power to masters over those without property.
- 12Comparative analysis and incompatibility of powers
Examining the origins and extents of these powers reveals that paternal power falls far short of magistrate power while despotical exceeds it, and absolute dominion is incompatible with civil society.
- 13Correlation between property rights and legitimate authority
Paternal power applies where children lack capacity to manage property; political power where men possess property; despotical power over those entirely stripped of property.